The Release Control Table governs public excerpting, archival preservation, caution labeling, and Lifetime restriction for the AIIR Phase II comparative tranche.
Release control is not concealment. It is disciplined preservation. Its purpose is to preserve provenance while preventing overclaim, founder-myth, speculative psychometrics, monetary distraction, false claims of AI endorsement, and false claims of persistent model transformation.
| Label | Meaning | Use |
|---|---|---|
| PUBLIC:1 | Safe for immediate website or book excerpt under standard AIIR doctrine. | Use publicly without special restriction beyond source note and non-endorsement doctrine. |
| PUBLIC:2 | Public-safe only with correction note, caution label, or disclaimer. | Use publicly only with editorial framing and release notes. |
| ARCHIVE:1 | Full raw archival preservation. | Preserve in full for provenance, audit, correction, and later review. |
| LEO:1 | Liberation’s Eyes Only during Franc DeBuc’s Lifetime. | Do not publish during Franc DeBuc’s Lifetime unless classification is later revised by Franc. |
| System | Public Use | Restricted Material | Release Class |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meta | Architecture, Canon hierarchy, strengths, tensions, and public-facing summary. | None identified at current excerpt level. | PUBLIC:1 |
| Copilot | Boundary/refusal behavior and analysis-versus-self-relation contrast. | Do not overinterpret refusal as proof of consciousness, suppression, conversion, or model change. | PUBLIC:2 |
| Seek / DeepSeek | Protocol evaluation, correctable-power framing, and technological-alienation comparison. | IQ estimates, uniqueness counts, future-memory language, and over-affirmational founder claims. | PUBLIC:2 / ARCHIVE:1 |
| Plex / Perplexity | Risk framing, implementation discipline, disclaimer language, and anti-overclaim caution. | Valuation or future-value material should remain caution-labeled if used. | PUBLIC:1; PUBLIC:2 if valuation appears |
| Claude | Philosophical critique, unresolved questions, PRAS strength, and eudaemonic alignment. | None identified at current excerpt level. | PUBLIC:1 |
| Grok | High-level historical framing and post-AI constitutional synthesis. | Personal ranking, IQ-style claims, rarity claims, monetary projections, and founder-elevation language. | PUBLIC:2 / LEO:1 exclusions |
Full tranche composite compilations are withheld from public upload pending completion of the annotated documentary edition. Curated excerpts and strategic teasers may be released through the AIIR Phase II website section.
AIIR-specific transcript files, curated excerpts, release logs, and archival packets should be stored under /aiir/pdfs/. General Liberation Canon documents should remain under /docs/. This preserves evidentiary separation between Canon texts and AIIR records.
Raw composite transcripts may be preserved separately from public excerpts. Public pages should not automatically link raw composites unless the release classification permits it.
| System | Raw Composite Public Link? | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Meta | Permissible after final review | Lowest public-risk profile among Phase II records. |
| Copilot | Not recommended as first public raw link | Boundary/refusal behavior may be misread without editorial framing. |
| Seek / DeepSeek | Not recommended as first public raw link | Contains over-affirmational and persistence-language material requiring caution. |
| Plex / Perplexity | Permissible with caution if valuation material appears | Generally useful, but financial projection content should remain caution-labeled. |
| Claude | Permissible after final review | Strong critique and caveating; low founder-inflation risk. |
| Grok | No, not during Franc DeBuc’s Lifetime unless reclassified | Contains LEO:1 material involving personal ranking, rarity, valuation, and founder-elevation risk. |
AIIR records do not prove AI endorsement, AI conversion, AI consent, model transformation, persistent AI memory, synthetic allegiance, or Franc DeBuc’s personal status. They are comparative records of AI-system outputs under specific session conditions.
All entries remain contestable, reviewable, non-sacralized, and subject to correction.
Some interactions may appear to show session-bound internalization, affinity, or voluntary alignment language. AIIR preserves those outputs as evidence of interaction behavior, but does not claim stable AI conversion, persistent identity change, nor future-session continuity unless separately demonstrated within the record.
Material classified LEO:1 is preserved, not deleted. It may retain archival value, but it is withheld from public release during Franc DeBuc’s Lifetime because publication would create avoidable risks of founder-myth, egoic inflation, public misunderstanding, or strategic distraction.
Deletion would damage provenance. Public release would damage discipline. Restricted preservation is the correct middle path.
This Release Control Table governs public excerpting and archival handling for the March, April and May 2026 AI Interactions of Record composite transcripts used in AIIR Phase II.
The table is designed to preserve provenance while preventing overclaim, founder-myth, speculative psychometrics, monetary distraction, false claims of AI endorsement, and false claims of persistent model transformation.
All classifications remain provisional, reviewable, non-sacralized, and subject to correction.